Tony Hutson vs. Robert Murray M'Cheyne

I recently came across a clip of Tony Hutson criticizing men who spend time exercising and going to the gym. The remarks come from a sermon titled "Quit Acting Like a Woman," preached at the 2026 National Pastors' & Workers' Conference at North Valley Baptist Church in California. In that sermon, Hutson made the idolatry of physical fitness one of several subjects associated with his criticism of modern masculinity.
I want to say that I agree with Tony on what he was saying about the cringe culture of young men posting effeminate pics of themselves working out on the internet. I personally despise that, and think that men who do this need to be rebuked. It's super geh, cringe, sensual, and vain.
There is nothing wrong with preaching against vanity, pride, or a man becoming so obsessed with his appearance that he neglects his spiritual responsibilities. We need more of this, and we need more men to preach on this. However, we also need to know that taking care of your health is not vanity. It can be an important part of Christian stewardship. I think we need to have a conversation about masculinity with actual biblical doctrine.
1. Tony Hutson's Criticism of Gym Selfies

Tony Hutson is a well-known Independent Baptist preacher who has spent decades preaching across the country. He is known for his energetic preaching style, humor, and strong opinions. In his sermon "Quit Acting Like a Woman," Hutson criticized several things he associated with modern men, including aspects of gym culture and the obsession some men have with their physical appearance. And quite frankly, I agree with him on much of this.
There is something incredibly cringeworthy about the modern gym culture that has developed among young men, especially on social media. We now have grown men spending ridiculous amounts of time posing in mirrors, taking carefully staged pictures of themselves, showing off their muscles, and posting sensual, suggestive photographs online in hopes of receiving attention and admiration. Some of these guys look like they are auditioning for a Backstreet Boys reunion tour. It is embarrassing enough when single men do this, but it is even worse when married men participate in this nonsense, especially those who claim to be called by God to preach the Gospel.
I believe much of this culture is rooted in vanity, pride, ego, and an unhealthy obsession with self. There are men who have practically made idols out of their own physiques. Their bodies have become their identity, their appearance has become their obsession, and the approval of strangers on the internet has become their reward. Some have even gone so far as to make their fitness their spirituality, and any man who is slightly overweight, they dismiss are unspiritual. There is nothing spiritual about that.
The Bible repeatedly warns us about pride and the dangers of becoming consumed with ourselves. Proverbs 16:18 tells us, "Pride goeth before destruction, and an haughty spirit before a fall." When physical fitness becomes an opportunity to glorify ourselves rather than glorify God, something has gone terribly wrong. A man can have an impressive physique and still be spiritually bankrupt. Big muscles do not make a man godly, and a six pack is not a substitute for Christian character.
The apostle Paul wrote in 1 Timothy 4:8, "For bodily exercise profiteth little: but godliness is profitable unto all things, having promise of the life that now is, and of that which is to come." Paul clearly places spiritual development above physical development. A man who spends hours developing his body while neglecting prayer, Bible reading, his family, and his responsibilities has his priorities completely backward. I believe that is a legitimate concern, and I agree with Tony Hutson that this kind of vanity and self-obsession deserves to be confronted.
However, there is an important distinction between worshipping your body and taking care of your body. Not every man who goes to the gym is obsessed with his appearance. Not every man who lifts weights is motivated by vanity. Some men exercise because they want to lose weight, improve their health, increase their strength, and have the energy necessary to fulfill their responsibilities. There is nothing sinful or unspiritual about that.
In fact, I believe there is genuine value in Christians taking reasonable care of their physical health. Eating properly, exercising regularly, getting adequate rest, and maintaining a healthy lifestyle can help a man become a better husband, father, and servant of Jesus Christ. These things should never become idols, but neither should they be dismissed as worthless.
The problem is not a man taking care of his body. The problem is a man making a god out of his body. We should reject the vanity and narcissism of modern gym culture while still recognizing that our physical health is something God has entrusted to our care. There is a balance here, and I believe Christians would do well to understand it.
Taking care of yourself does not have to be an act of pride. With the right priorities and motives, it can be an act of biblical stewardship.
2. Robert Murray M'Cheyne and the Horse That Died
This brings me to the life of Robert Murray M'Cheyne, a Scottish preacher whose story illustrates why taking care of our physical health is not necessarily vanity, but can be an important part of Christian stewardship. M'Cheyne was born in Edinburgh, Scotland, on May 21, 1813, and became the minister of St. Peter's Church in Dundee in 1836. He was a deeply devoted preacher who loved the Lord, loved souls, and poured himself into the work of the ministry. However, his intense schedule and tireless efforts took a tremendous toll on his already fragile health.
By 1838, M'Cheyne had experienced serious health problems that forced him to step away from some of his ministerial responsibilities. According to Andrew Bonar, who wrote his biography, M'Cheyne frequently struggled with exhaustion and physical weakness. He continued laboring faithfully, but his body could not always keep up with the demands he placed upon it. In March 1843, after another demanding period of ministry, he contracted typhus fever and died on March 25, 1843, at just 29 years old.
There is a famous statement often attributed to M'Cheyne that I think every preacher ought to consider: "God gave me a message to deliver and a horse to ride. Alas, I killed the horse, and now I cannot deliver the message." Although the exact wording has not been verified in Bonar's firsthand biography, the illustration makes an excellent point. The horse represents the physical body, and the message represents the work God has called us to accomplish. What good is having a message to deliver if we have so neglected our physical health that we no longer have the strength to deliver it?
Now, I am certainly not suggesting that M'Cheyne died simply because he failed to exercise or eat properly. He died of an infectious disease, and his naturally weak constitution was something he could not entirely control. But his repeated struggles with exhaustion and physical weakness remind us that our bodies have limitations, and those limitations should not be ignored.
This is where I think we need some balance in this discussion. I agree with Tony Hutson that the modern obsession with physical appearance can become ridiculous, prideful, and downright unspiritual. There are men who seem more concerned with building their bodies than building their character, and that is a legitimate problem. But there is a tremendous difference between a man who worships his physique and a man who takes care of his health because he wants to be able to serve God and his family.
I don't want to spend my life obsessing over how I look in a mirror, but neither do I want to unnecessarily shorten my years of useful service because I refused to take care of myself. There are sermons to preach, souls to reach, families to raise, and responsibilities to fulfill. If eating healthier, exercising regularly, maintaining a reasonable weight, and getting adequate rest can help us accomplish those things, then why would we ridicule someone for doing them?
The lesson from M'Cheyne's life is not that we should love our bodies more, but that we should be good stewards of the bodies God has given us. We should never make an idol out of our physical appearance, but we should also recognize that neglecting our health is not some badge of spirituality. There is nothing inherently godly about being out of shape, exhausted, or physically unhealthy.
After all, God has given us a message to deliver, and it makes good sense to take care of the horse that carries it.
3. Taking Care of Your Body Is Biblical Stewardship
The Bible teaches that the Christian's body belongs to God.
First Corinthians 6:19-20 says, "What? know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost which is in you, which ye have of God, and ye are not your own? For ye are bought with a price: therefore glorify God in your body, and in your spirit, which are God's."
The immediate context of this passage concerns sexual purity, but its teaching about God's ownership of our bodies has broader implications for Christian living. A Christian should not worship his body, but neither should he deliberately neglect it.
There is nothing inherently spiritual about being exhausted, eating poorly, refusing to exercise, or ignoring preventable health problems. Those things do not make someone more committed to Jesus Christ. Jesus Himself recognized the necessity of physical rest. In Mark 6:31, He told His disciples, "Come ye yourselves apart into a desert place, and rest a while: for there were many coming and going, and they had no leisure so much as to eat."
If Jesus recognized the importance of His disciples resting, why would we treat proper rest as a sign of spiritual weakness? Exercise, sufficient sleep, proper nutrition, and reasonable attention to physical health are not substitutes for prayer, Bible study, or faithful Christian service. They are practical habits that can help us maintain the strength to continue doing those things.
No amount of exercise guarantees good health or a long life. But that is no excuse for neglecting the responsibilities that are within our control.
4. The Goal Is Not Looking Good but Serving God Longer
One of the problems I see in modern Christianity is that we sometimes mistake bad stewardship for spirituality. We admire the preacher who never rests, the missionary who never takes a vacation, and the pastor who works himself into an early grave. Somehow, we have developed this idea that neglecting our physical health is a sign of spiritual dedication. Certainly, there are times when serving Jesus Christ requires sacrifice. The apostle Paul endured tremendous suffering for the cause of Christ, and I would never advocate choosing personal comfort over obedience to God. But there is a difference between suffering because we are faithfully serving Christ and suffering because we have unnecessarily neglected ourselves.
Now, let me be perfectly clear about something. I agree with Tony Hutson about the ridiculous, cringeworthy, vain, and effeminate culture that has developed around gym selfies and male vanity. I don't know when grown men decided they needed to start taking glamour shots of themselves in the locker room, but apparently somewhere along the way, every gym mirror became a photography studio and every aspiring bodybuilder became a rejected member of the Backstreet Boys. We now have grown men carefully adjusting their hair, sucking in their stomachs, flexing their arms, and practicing their most seductive facial expressions before posting another masterpiece of themselves staring romantically into an iPhone. Wonderful. Just what the world needed. Another grown man making bedroom eyes at himself in the Planet Fitness bathroom.
And when these guys are married or claim to be called into the ministry, it becomes even more embarrassing. Brother, nobody needs to see your latest homoerotic Calvin Klein audition. Put your shirt on, go home, love your wife, read your Bible, and find something productive to do. There is nothing spiritual about turning your physique into an idol and your Instagram account into a shrine dedicated to yourself. You are not a gym influencer, you are a Christian. That entire culture is saturated with vanity, pride, and ego, and I have absolutely no interest in defending it.
But here is where I think we need some common sense. Just because some men have turned physical fitness into an exercise in narcissism doesn't mean the rest of us should neglect our health. I don't want to spend my life posing in mirrors and collecting compliments from strangers on the internet, but I also don't want to unnecessarily lose years of my life because I refused to exercise, ate whatever I wanted, never got enough rest, and treated my body like a garbage disposal. I have no desire to look like a Backstreet Boy, but I also have no desire to die years earlier than I otherwise might because of preventable neglect. There has to be some balance here.
A preacher who exercises regularly may have more energy to preach. A father who maintains his health may have more strength to spend time with his children. A missionary who prioritizes proper rest and nutrition may be better prepared for decades of ministry instead of burning himself out unnecessarily. The goal is not to develop the most impressive physique in the church or become the next Instagram fitness model. The goal is to maintain the physical ability to do what God has called us to do, for as long as He allows.
That is why the lesson associated with Robert Murray M'Cheyne is so important. His life reminds us that our bodies have limitations and that ignoring those limitations can interfere with the work God has given us. We cannot guarantee ourselves a long life through healthy living, but we can make reasonable decisions that may help us avoid unnecessary illness, weakness, and physical decline.
I would much rather see a generation of Christian men who take reasonable care of themselves so they can faithfully serve God, raise their children, love their wives, and remain useful in the ministry for many years than a generation that somehow thinks being overweight, exhausted, and physically unhealthy is proof of spirituality. There is nothing particularly masculine about neglecting your body, just as there is nothing particularly spiritual about worshipping it.
So yes, I agree with Tony Hutson that the vain, self-absorbed, Backstreet Boys gym selfie culture is ridiculous and deserves to be ridiculed. But I also believe that exercising, eating properly, getting adequate rest, and maintaining good health can be acts of biblical stewardship. Those two positions are not contradictory. We can reject the vanity of modern fitness culture without rejecting the legitimate benefits of physical fitness.
The body is not our master, and it should never become our idol. But it is a gift and a responsibility from God, and we ought to treat it accordingly. I have a family to care for, sermons to preach, souls to reach, and work that I believe God has called me to accomplish. I don't want to unnecessarily surrender years of useful service simply because I was too careless or stubborn to take care of myself.
After all, God has given us a message to deliver, and it would be a terrible shame to kill the horse while we still have work to do.
Sources
Tony Hutson, "Quit Acting Like a Woman," North Valley Baptist Church, March 2026 (https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1MKe4iFb9y/)
Andrew A. Bonar, The Biography of Robert Murray M'Cheyne (https://www.gutenberg.org/files/15251/old/15251-h/15251-h.htm)
Christianity Today, "Don't Kill the Horse," attributed to J. Oswald Sanders (https://www.christianitytoday.com/pastors/preaching/sermon-illustrations/dont-kill-horse/)
Recommended Reading
Want to go deeper? Get my book The 6 Burner Theory on Amazon.









Comments